OK, now I get it.

I just peeked in to look at the menu of a restaurant near where I work. It had a number of items:

This: $18.00
That: $22.00
The Other: $30.00

and notably:

Lobster: $54.00

Which means I finally get the joke from Mystery Men:

We’ve got a blind date with Destiny—and it looks like she’s ordered the lobster

Yeah, I’m pretty slow.